Notes on "Tomographic reconstruction of 630.0 nm emission structure for a polar cap arc" by Doe, Kelly, Semeter and Steele Abstract: "in tandem" means in a fore-and-aft configuration; is this what we mean? Perhaps "concurrently"? 1. Introduction Paragraph 1, line 15: change "... evolution for the source ..." to "... evolution of the source ..." Paragraph 3, lines 9-13: change "... constrains the timescale for changes in the magnetospheric electron source and the timescale for thermospheric processes such as plasma and atomic oxygen transport." to "... limits the time resolution with which the effects of changes in the magnetospheric electron source and thermospheric processes such as plasma and atomic oxygen transport may be observed." 2. Campaign Overview Paragraph 1, line 5: change "80.2° N, long. 274.1°" to "80.1° N, long. 273.6°" Paragraph 1, line 15: change "overlain" to "overlaid" 3. Image Photometric Calibration Paragraph 2, line 3: change "16-bit" to "14-bit" Paragraph 3: Expand discussion of how images were interpolated in time. 5. Discussion Paragraph 3, line 7: add an "s" to "remain" Paragraph 3, line 15: add a comma after "that is" Paragraph 3, line 19: "plasm" should be "plasma" Paragraph 3, lines 18-21: How sensitive is the bottomside shape to downward plasma transport? I would have thought the dominance of O(1D) quenching would have made the effects of reasonable amounts of downward transport hard to detect. What do I mean by "reasonable"? - I don't know. Paragraph 4, line 2: recommend changing "315 km" to "300 km" since that's where the slope departs from that of profiles 1 and 2 Paragraph 5, line 7: change "auroral impact" to "auroral electron impact" Paragraph 7, line 13: change "effect the 350 to 500 km regime." to "model the 350 to 500 km regime correctly." 6. Conclusion Paragraph 1, line 17: "consistant" should be "consistent" Paragraph 2, line 2: change "radarwave" to "radiowave" Acknowledgments. change "grant XXX-XXXX." to "a CSA contract under the CNSR Transition Program." Figure 1: The only real problem is that Eureka is not positioned symmetrically in the field of view. I would be satisfied if your illustrator could move it outward, parallel to the 15 MLT meridian, to its correct PACE latitude of 88.6 deg. Plate 1: change "for the evolution" to "of the evolution"? change "overlaping" to "overlapping"